Need Help? Get a Free Case Evaluation
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Pat McWhirter Personal Injury Attorney Desktop Headshot Pat McWhirter Personal Injury Attorney Mobile Headshot

Top Reasons Workers’ Compensation Claims Are Denied

Top Reasons Workers' Compensation Claims Are Denied

Facing an injury at the workplace can be a challenging experience, both physically and emotionally. In South Carolina, the workers’ compensation system is designed to provide financial support and medical benefits to employees who suffer work-related injuries or illnesses. However, not all claims are automatically accepted, and denials can be disheartening. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the top reasons workers’ compensation claims are denied in South Carolina and provide practical strategies on how to handle such denials.

Denial Reason #1: Failure to Report the Injury Promptly

One of the most common reasons for workers’ compensation claim denials in South Carolina is the failure to report the injury promptly. State regulations require employees to notify their employers about workplace injuries within 90 days of the incident. Delays in reporting can raise questions about the legitimacy of the claim, making it essential for employees to communicate the details of their injuries as soon as possible.

How to Avoid it:

If you’ve experienced a workplace injury, report it to your employer immediately, providing detailed information about the incident. Be aware of the 90-day reporting window and ensure your account is accurate and thorough. If there were any delays due to unforeseen circumstances, document them and explain the reasons for the delay in your claim.

Denial Reason #2: Lack of Medical Evidence or Documentation

A workers’ compensation claim relies heavily on medical evidence to establish the link between the injury and the workplace. In some cases, claims are denied due to insufficient or inconsistent medical documentation. Failing to seek timely medical attention, not following prescribed treatment plans, or neglecting to attend medical evaluations can jeopardize the credibility of the claim.

How to Avoid it:

Seek medical attention promptly after the injury and adhere to the treatment plan outlined by your healthcare provider. Attend all scheduled medical evaluations and keep detailed records of your medical history, treatment, and any correspondence with healthcare professionals. Providing a comprehensive medical trail strengthens your case and makes it harder for insurers to dispute the validity of your claim.

Denial Reason #3: Disputes Over the Nature of the Injury

Sometimes, employers and insurance carriers may contest the nature and severity of the injury. They might argue that the injury is not work-related or that it doesn’t warrant the claimed level of compensation. Disputes over pre-existing conditions or whether the injury occurred within the scope of employment can lead to claim denials.

How to Avoid it:

Clearly articulate how the injury occurred within the scope of your employment and provide any evidence, such as eyewitness accounts or surveillance footage, if available. If a pre-existing condition contributed to the injury, demonstrate how the workplace incident aggravated or accelerated the condition. Consult with a workers’ compensation attorney to build a strong case supporting the work-related nature of your injury.

Denial Reason #4: Missed Filing Deadlines

In South Carolina, there are specific deadlines for filing workers’ compensation claims. Failure to adhere to these deadlines can result in automatic claim denials. The filing deadlines can vary based on factors such as the type of injury and whether it involves lost time from work.

How to Avoid it:

Stay informed about the deadlines for filing workers’ compensation claims in South Carolina. File the necessary forms, such as Form 50 or Form 52, within the stipulated time frame. If you encounter challenges or are unsure about the deadlines, seek legal advice promptly to ensure your claim is not dismissed on procedural grounds.

Denial Reason #5: Employee Misconduct or Violation of Workplace Policies

Workers’ compensation claims may be denied if the injury resulted from an employee’s willful misconduct or violation of workplace safety policies. If the employer can demonstrate that the injury occurred due to the employee’s intentional disregard for safety rules, the claim may be rejected.

How to Avoid it:

Be proactive in adhering to workplace safety guidelines and policies. If there are disputes regarding your compliance with safety rules, provide evidence showing that you followed proper procedures and that the injury resulted from factors beyond your control. Seeking legal counsel can help navigate complexities related to alleged misconduct.

Denial Reason #6: Lack of Witness Statements or Documentation

In some cases, a lack of witness statements or supporting documentation can lead to claim denials. If there were no immediate witnesses to the incident or if the details are unclear, insurers may question the authenticity of the claim.

How to Avoid it:

Document the details of the incident as thoroughly as possible. If there were witnesses, gather their names and contact information. Photographs, video footage, or any other relevant documentation can strengthen your case. Presenting a clear and detailed account of the events can help overcome challenges related to the absence of witnesses.

Denial Reason #7: Independent Medical Examination (IME) Findings

In certain situations, the workers’ compensation insurance carrier may request an independent medical examination (IME) to assess the extent of the injury and the need for ongoing treatment. If the IME findings differ significantly from those of your treating physician, it may lead to a denial of your claim.

How to Avoid it:

While you cannot control the outcome of an IME, you can prepare for it. Ensure that your treating physician has thoroughly documented your injuries and the necessity for specific treatments. Provide the IME physician with accurate and comprehensive information about your condition. If there are discrepancies, consult with your attorney to address these issues during the claims process.

Denial Reason #8: Employer’s Dispute of the Claim

Employers and insurance carriers may dispute workers’ compensation claims based on their interpretation of the events leading to the injury. They may argue that the injury did not occur in the course of employment, or they may contest the severity of the injuries claimed.

How to Avoid it: 

Engage in open communication with your employer and their insurance carrier. Clearly present your side of the story, backed by any evidence or documentation available. If the dispute persists, consult with a workers’ compensation attorney who can advocate for your rights and negotiate with the employer or insurance company on your behalf.


Facing a denial of a workers’ compensation claim can be daunting, but it’s important to remember that the process doesn’t end with a denial. Understanding the common reasons for denials in South Carolina and implementing effective strategies to address these issues can significantly improve the chances of a successful claim.

Prompt reporting, comprehensive medical documentation, adherence to deadlines, and effective communication with all parties involved are key elements in overcoming common hurdles in the workers’ compensation claim process. Seeking legal advice early in the process can provide invaluable support in navigating the complexities of the system and ensuring your rights are protected as you pursue the benefits you deserve.

Contact The Workers’ Comp Lawyers From McWhirter, Bellinger & Associates Today

Getting injured at work can be physically and emotionally damaging, and having your workers’ compensation claim get denied can add worry and stress to an already stressful situation. Unfortunately, many people drop their claims after they are denied, assuming it’s a lost cause. However, that’s not always the case. 

Personal injury attorneys devote their professional lives to helping their clients, and that often means helping them through denials and appeals. Injured workers may feel defeated after a workers’ compensation denial, but experienced workers’ compensation lawyers know that many denials are simply hurdles that can be overcome. 

At McWhirter, Bellinger & Associates, we are not deterred by denials to legitimate workers’ compensation claims. Instead, we combine our knowledge and experience to build the strongest cases possible for our clients so they can receive what they are rightfully owed.

When you hire a McWhirter, Bellinger & Associates attorney, you are hiring a professional who understands the law and how to navigate the South Carolina workers’ compensation system. Our workers’ comp lawyers have a reputation for working hard to achieve great outcomes for their clients, even in cases that are not particularly straightforward.

Our law firm offers free case evaluations to injured workers in South Carolina, so give us a call today at 888-353-5513. It won’t cost you anything to see if we can help.®